Noni Madueke dragged Arsenal to a 2-2 draw at St James’ Park on Saturday night, and on an evening when the champions let a deserved lead slip and lost David Raya to a shoulder injury, he was the one player who never stopped hurting Newcastle.
Eberechi Eze put Arsenal ahead after 33 minutes, and the first half was as one-sided as it gets. Newcastle managed an xG of just 0.08 before the break. Then Matthias Jaissle made three changes at half-time, Martin Odegaard gave the ball away for Harvey Barnes to equalise, and Malick Thiaw turned the game around from a yard out.
Madueke’s low drive 12 minutes from time rescued a point. It ends Arsenal’s run of five straight Premier League wins, but Mikel Arteta’s side are still six points clear of Brighton, who play on Sunday. Here is how every Arsenal player rated.
Arsenal player ratings vs Newcastle: the goalkeeper
David Raya: 5
A brave start to the second half, diving at Joe Willock’s feet and taking a bang to the head for his trouble. He shook it off, but the decision on 62 minutes was poor: under pressure after Eze slipped near his own goal, he lashed the ball out for a corner, and Newcastle scored from it.
Five minutes later he was flat on his back after a small touch from William Osula, holding his shoulder. He left with a physio on 70 minutes, and that may be the biggest story of the night for Arsenal.
How did the back four cope?
Jurrien Timber: 6
Quiet but tidy for most of it, and he had to stand up to a heavy challenge from Dan Burn late on, which sparked the pushing that got Burn and Madueke booked. He was the target of Gabriel’s cut-back in the closing minutes, but Jacob Ramsey cleared.
Ezri Konsa: 5
Comfortable while Newcastle offered nothing in the first half. In stoppage time he dithered on the ball and Barnes nicked it off him, and only a cross that dropped into Kepa Arrizabalaga’s hands spared him.
Gabriel Magalhaes: 6
Solid in the air for most of the night and almost created a late winner, picking up a lovely flick from Odegaard in the box and trying to find Timber. The marking at the corner that led to Thiaw’s goal, with Burn completely free at the back post, will be looked at by the whole defence.
Riccardo Calafiori: 6
Did plenty right going forward. It was his throw-in that started the move before Odegaard’s mistake, though the error itself was not his.
Midfield: where the game turned
Bruno Guimaraes: 6
Booed from the first minute on his first return to Tyneside since his summer move, and the home fans cheered as he was taken off on 70 minutes. He did his job in a first half Arsenal controlled, then got dragged into the chaos like everyone else. There were hugs from his old team-mates at full-time and boos when he applauded the crowd.
Declan Rice: 5
Booked on 56 minutes for barging Lewis Hall in the back as Newcastle found their feet. In the ninth minute of stoppage time Barnes beat him for pace and set up Jacob Ramsey for a chance he should have taken. A rare off night.
The attack: Madueke and the rest
Noni Madueke: 8, our man of the match
Five shots in the first half alone, the joint most by any player in a first half in the Premier League this season, and he had Lewis Hall on toast down the right for long spells. We flagged that battle in our key battles before the game, and Madueke won it.
His goal came at the end of a move that cut Newcastle open from one end to the other. He came inside onto his left foot and drove low through the gloves of Lukas Hornicek, who got two hands to it and should probably have kept it out. Madueke will not care. He also picked up a booking for joining in the pushing with England team-mate Burn.
Martin Odegaard: 4
The captain’s night will be remembered for one moment. Under pressure from Willock after a throw-in four minutes into the second half, he sliced the ball, got pushed off it, and Osula teed up Barnes to finish low past Raya. It was an uncharacteristic mistake and it changed the whole game. His corners and a late flick for Gabriel were good, and he made way for Viktor Gyokeres in stoppage time.
Eberechi Eze: 7
Scored his first league goal of the season, finishing high into the net after Kai Havertz had won the ball. His slip near his own goal led to the corner for Newcastle’s second, which takes a little off his evening. Replaced on 70 minutes.
Kai Havertz: 6
Superb to rob Hall and thread the pass for Eze’s goal, and he did a lot of good work at both ends, including a header clear from a Hall free-kick. He also looped a header off the top of his own bar from a corner on 74 minutes, which was an anxious moment for everyone in red. Off for Mikel Merino in stoppage time.
What did the substitutes add?
Kepa Arrizabalaga: 7
Thrown on at 2-1 down with his team-mate in pain, and within six minutes he made a brave stop when Lewis Miley powered through. He also dealt calmly with a late cross. If Raya is out for a while, this was a useful reminder that Arsenal have a capable number two.
Myles Lewis-Skelly: 5
Lost the ball in the middle soon after coming on, which let Willock run at the Arsenal defence and win a corner.
Christos Tzolis: 5
Plenty of energy, but caught offside more than once when Arsenal were finally getting into good areas.
Viktor Gyokeres and Mikel Merino: no rating
Both came on in the fourth minute of stoppage time. Gyokeres whipped one chance into the crowd and was booked after the final whistle for something he said to the referee. With the Swede on the bench until the 94th minute in a game Arsenal needed to win, his role is a question Arteta will keep being asked.
Newcastle 2-2 Arsenal verdict: a point that felt like two dropped
This was only the second time in the last 23 Premier League games where Arsenal led at half-time that they failed to win. The pattern is familiar: dominant, but not ruthless enough to put the game away. No Arsenal player has more than three league goals this season, and with Bukayo Saka and Martin Zubimendi both injured, the attack is leaning heavily on Madueke right now.
Credit to Newcastle too. Jaissle’s half-time changes, with Tino Livramento, Jacob Ramsey and Anthony Elanga all coming on, changed the energy of the game, and Willock dropping deeper gave them a spark in midfield. Our predicted lineup had Bruno back on Tyneside, and he got the welcome everyone expected.
A point at St James’ Park is not a disaster, especially with Manchester City failing to beat Fulham earlier on Saturday. The real worry is Raya’s shoulder.













