Arsenal’s greatest strength under Mikel Arteta might also be the thing that stops them from being truly ruthless: they read opponents so well that they sometimes end up playing the game the other team wants.
That sounds like a strange complaint about a side that are five points clear at the top, have won five Premier League games in a row and have kept four straight league clean sheets. It is not a crisis. It is a habit, and St James’ Park on Saturday at 5.30pm is exactly the kind of place where it can cost points.
With Bukayo Saka still out and Borussia Dortmund coming to the Emirates on Tuesday, the question is not whether Arsenal can grind out another result. It is whether they can make a team like Newcastle defend the way Arsenal want, rather than the other way round.
Are Arsenal too good at adapting?
In one sense, no. The biggest misconception about this team is that the football is boring. What Arsenal actually do better than any of their rivals is adapt from game to game. The plan for Slavia Prague was not the plan for Hull City, and neither looked like the plan for Liverpool at Anfield, where Kai Havertz’s early goal from a Declan Rice cross was enough.
Kieran Tierney once described how Arteta could tell his players what was going to happen in a match before it happened, and then it did. That level of preparation is a gift. In a league where every game is micromanaged by analysts, Arsenal are top of the class.
But there is a shadow to everything. If you prepare perfectly for what Nottingham Forest or Hull are going to do, there is a risk you end up reacting to them rather than forcing them to react to you.
What ‘mirror image’ football looks like
We have seen it a few times this season. The opposition sits in a back five, so Arsenal shift Havertz across, recycle the ball, play fewer crosses because there are more bodies in the box, and wait for the gap. The logic is sound. The trouble is that it hands the opponent the game they came for.
Sometimes the better answer is simpler: play your own game and make them unable to defend that way. Put two men inside instead of one. Overload the box. Ask a question they did not prepare for. Nobody wants Arsenal to swap control for chaos, and we would much rather be here than at the other end of the table, but a little more of that bravery would turn some of these 1-0 wins into comfortable afternoons.
The 1-0 against Hull was the perfect example. Martin Odegaard only scored when he followed up Noni Madueke’s saved shot, and for long spells the champions played at Hull’s tempo. Against a team Arsenal are clearly better than, that is the type of game that should be four or five.
Why the set-piece goals matter more than they look
Last season a corner would have broken that Hull game open. This season it hasn’t happened. As we set out in our look at how Arsenal’s corner goals have crashed, only 1.8% of their corners in the first ten league games ended in a goal, down from 8.8% last season, even though they are winning almost exactly the same number.
That matters for the reason above. An early goal changes the game state. It forces a deep block to come out, and suddenly the opposition has to answer a different question. We saw it against Everton on 24 October, when Ezri Konsa’s seventh-minute opener set up a 2-0 win. When the dead-ball goals are not coming, Arsenal need another way to land that first punch.
Where does the chaos come from?
If Arsenal want to dictate rather than mirror, they need players who can do something nobody planned for. With Saka out, that job falls to a group of attackers who all come with question marks.
Eberechi Eze, the maverick in a system team
Eze is the most interesting case. He was an unused substitute at Anfield, where Arteta said “we had an issue with Ebs as well”, and at 28 he is still working out where he fits. He is not really a touchline winger, and with Odegaard in this form the central role is taken.
Yet nobody else in this squad has his kind of improvisation. Think of him as the guest who won’t start the party but makes a good one far better. He will not be the weekly talisman that Rice is, but in the moments when a tight game needs one flash of brilliance, he is the man most likely to provide it. Arteta has to meet him halfway, and Eze has to meet Arsenal halfway too, because the Crystal Palace version of him will not work in this system. It would not take much for him to reach a very different level.
Viktor Gyokeres is not the flop he is made out to be
The other lightning rod is Viktor Gyokeres. The criticism has gone too far, bordering on bullying in places. He arrived from Sporting CP in July 2025 for an initial €63.5m, not the kind of fee that should be compared with Erling Haaland, and he scored 21 goals in all competitions last season. It is hard to see Arsenal winning the title without them.
Yes, his first touch can be clunky. Yes, there are days when he looks cumbersome and frustrated. But there are other days, like his goal and assist in Prague, when he bullies centre-backs and the hold-up play gives Arsenal a different outlet. He was built up as the saviour, and now the pendulum has swung too far the other way. He has started only once in the league this season, behind Havertz, and as a power option from the bench at St James’ Park he is exactly the kind of player who can change the question a defence has to answer.
Noni Madueke has found another gear
The one attacker who has properly grabbed his chance is Madueke. He has started slowing himself down in the box and making calmer decisions, and his ability to shift a defender inside and go is something almost nobody can stop. We explained how Arteta’s Saka stand-in changed our minds. The next step is simple: goals and assists.
Arsenal tactics at St James’ Park: impose, don’t mirror
Newcastle will press for the first 20 minutes with the crowd behind them, and Arteta will have a plan for every bit of it. That is the reassuring part. The part we want to see is what comes after, when Arsenal have the ball and Newcastle settle into a shape.
Our Arsenal predicted lineup vs Newcastle has the same eleven that beat Hull, with Havertz up front. That is the safe call. But if the game is tight at the hour, we want Eze and Gyokeres on early, two men in the box, and Arsenal asking the questions rather than answering them.
Winning can hide a lot. Right now it is hiding very little: a slightly reactive streak and a set-piece threat that has gone quiet. Fix those, and this side goes from champions who grind to champions who flatten people.












