Kepa Arrizabalaga could be in goal for Arsenal against Borussia Dortmund on Tuesday and Manchester City next Sunday, and Jamie Redknapp does not think he is ready for it.
David Raya has an MRI scan on Sunday after he was helped off at St James’ Park holding his left shoulder. Kepa replaced him for the last 20 minutes of the 2-2 draw with Newcastle United, and Arsenal still left Tyneside six points clear at the top of the Premier League.
Nobody knows yet how long Raya will be out, if at all. Mikel Arteta said after the game that it was “not good news” and that the club would know more on Sunday. But the next fortnight is about as hard as it gets, and the question on every Gooner’s mind is a simple one: can Arsenal cope with their No 2?
Why Redknapp calls Raya “irreplaceable”
Redknapp was blunt on Sky Sports after the final whistle. He pointed out that Arsenal have cover everywhere else, and that the goalkeeper is the exception.
“Arsenal’s squad, they have two players in every position. The fact that their goalkeeper David Raya walked off that pitch, he looked like he was in severe pain. That is the one player that is irreplaceable in that team,” he said.
He did not hold back on the man who came on, either. “Kepa is not up to the level of him. I actually think he struggles in the Premier League. Obviously we’ve seen him in the Carabao Cup last year in the final,” Redknapp added. “He’s now going to have to play some games and that’s going to be difficult for him and that will change everything for Arsenal for a while.”
He finished by calling Raya “probably the best goalkeeper in the Premier League, if not one of the best in the world”, and the numbers back him up. Raya kept seven clean sheets in Arsenal’s first ten league games of the season, and Arsenal had won their last four league games without conceding before Saturday.
How did Kepa do at St James’ Park?
Better than the doom suggests. Raya went down after a light touch from William Osula on 67 minutes and could not carry on, so Kepa came on with Arsenal 2-1 down and Newcastle on top.
He had to be brave straight away, keeping out Lewis Miley after a quick Newcastle move, and he gathered a stoppage-time cross after Harvey Barnes had nicked the ball. In between, Noni Madueke made it 2-2 at the other end. It was not a busy 20 minutes, but it was a calm one, and we gave him a 7 in our Arsenal player ratings vs Newcastle.
The worry is not one cameo. It is what happens when he has to start against the best teams in Europe, back to back, with no time to settle.
Madueke: “I don’t know if we were too relaxed”
The goalkeeping problem came out of a second half that Arsenal should never have let happen. They led through Eberechi Eze at the break and had 18 touches in the Newcastle box to their hosts’ one, then fell apart after Martin Odegaard’s miscued volley let Barnes in to equalise.
Madueke, who rescued the point with a dummy and a slightly deflected finish on 78 minutes, was honest about it. “The second half, we weren’t at our standard in the first 20 minutes and when you give this crowd and team belief it’s difficult. In the end I think 2-2 is a fair result,” he said.
“You know what to expect from Newcastle at home. The first 20 minutes of the second half is us not sticking by our own principles. I don’t know if we were too relaxed after our first-half performance.”
That fits what Arteta said too, in his own verdict on two dropped points at Newcastle. Against Dortmund and City, a 20-minute lapse like that will cost far more than two points, especially with a new man behind the back four.
Arsenal’s next five games without Raya
If the scan brings bad news, this is the run Kepa walks into. Two of the five are Champions League nights, and the Premier League games include a title rival and the north London derby.
| Date | Fixture | Competition | Kick-off (UK) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tuesday 24 November | Arsenal vs Borussia Dortmund | Champions League | 8pm |
| Sunday 29 November | Arsenal vs Manchester City | Premier League | 4.30pm |
| Wednesday 2 December | Brentford vs Arsenal | Premier League | 8.15pm |
| Sunday 6 December | Tottenham Hotspur vs Arsenal | Premier League | 4.30pm |
| Wednesday 9 December | Arsenal vs Real Madrid | Champions League | 8pm |
The City game is the one that jumps out. Manchester City drew with Fulham on Saturday and sit third on 22 points, six behind Arsenal on 28, so a win at the Emirates would cut the gap to three. Brighton, second on 22, can close it to three themselves at Hull City on Sunday.
Who else is there?
Behind Kepa, Arsenal have Illan Meslier, who joined on a free in the summer. He gives Arteta a third senior goalkeeper, which matters if Kepa is now playing twice a week, but Kepa is the clear next in line and he is the one who finished the game on Saturday.
Arsenal are already without Bukayo Saka and Martin Zubimendi, as Arteta confirmed before the trip, and you can read how Raya’s shoulder injury happened at Newcastle in full.
Verdict: Kepa has to be ready for Man City, whatever the scan says
Redknapp may well be right that there is a drop from Raya to Kepa. There is a drop from Raya to almost every keeper in this league. But Arsenal’s title push will not be decided by whether Kepa is as good as Raya. It will be decided by whether the ten men in front of him stop giving away 20-minute spells like the one on Tyneside.
Kepa looked calm when he came on, and he has a Champions League home game against Dortmund to find his feet before City arrive. If Raya is out for a few weeks, that is the plan Arteta has to sell, and the dressing room has to buy into it. If the scan is kind, all of this becomes a bad scare and nothing more. We will know on Sunday.












