Analysis

Booed or applauded? Bruno Guimarães goes back to Newcastle with Shearer predicting a frosty night, and Arteta should start him

Bruno Guimarães Arsenal

Bruno Guimarães goes back to St James’ Park on Saturday for the first time since his £75m move to Arsenal, and Alan Shearer does not think Newcastle United fans will make it a warm night.

The Brazilian spent four and a half years on Tyneside, captained the club and lifted the Carabao Cup as skipper. Then, 15 days before the new season, he flew into Newcastle’s La Manga training camp to tell Matthias Jaissle, sporting director Ross Wilson and chief executive David Hopkinson that he wanted to go.

So how will he be received, what has he said about it, and should Mikel Arteta start him at 5.30pm on Saturday? Here is our take.

What reception will Bruno Guimarães get at Newcastle?

Probably a frosty one. Shearer was asked about it on All Out Football and was blunt: “I don’t think it’ll be as bad as Isak, but I don’t think it’ll be a good reception.”

He went on: “Ultimately Bruno wanted to leave, which is fine. Everyone has their opinion and wants to move club at times. But he wanted to leave and he didn’t want to be there any longer, and I get that and understand that, but sometimes fans of your football club, or our football club, don’t understand that.”

The Alexander Isak comparison matters. Isak was booed from start to finish on his return in August after his move to Liverpool, and Jaissle has already said that a hostile atmosphere helped his team that day. He has not tried to discourage a repeat.

Why did Bruno leave Newcastle?

He has been open about it. Speaking to ESPN before the game, Bruno said: “I think I was one of the most beloved players during my time there, so it was a difficult decision, but in my mind, deep down, I felt I needed a new challenge.”

“After almost five years at Newcastle, I think I’m driven by challenges and wanted a new one,” he added. He also pointed to the timing, right after a turbulent World Cup, and admitted it “wasn’t an easy decision.”

Newcastle told him he was still wanted. He handed in a transfer request anyway, knowing Arsenal were waiting, and the hole he left is still there: they lost a captain and the midfielder who carried the ball out of pressure in the big games.

How has Bruno done at Arsenal so far?

It has been a slower start than the fee suggests. He has started four Premier League games and has mostly been part of Arteta’s rotation, a long way from the player Newcastle built their midfield around for four years.

He knows it. “I think I’m increasingly understanding Arteta’s approach, which is completely different from what I was used to doing at Newcastle, and I’m adapting more and more, getting to know the new players better,” he said. “It’s not easy to switch clubs after nearly five years, when you were already completely used to the routine.”

The last game before the break was a step forward. He started next to Declan Rice in the 1-0 win over Hull City, which we covered in our Arsenal 1-0 Hull City report.

Should Arteta start Bruno against Newcastle?

We think he will, and we think he should. Martin Zubimendi hurt his hamstring with Spain and is a major doubt, as set out in our Arsenal injury news before Newcastle, so the place next to Rice is open.

There is a case for protecting him from the noise. We do not buy it. Bruno knows that ground, those fans and that dressing room better than anyone in Arsenal’s squad, and a player who asked for a new challenge should want this one. Mikel Merino is the alternative if Arteta prefers to keep things calm.

The discipline question

The one worry is his temper. Chris Kavanagh is the referee, he has shown 62 yellow cards and five reds in 13 games this season, and he booked Bruno in Newcastle’s 1-0 win over Wolves at St James’ Park in September 2025. On a night when every tackle will be cheered or jeered, Bruno needs to stay on the right side of him.

What Newcastle are saying

Not everyone in black and white is bitter. Dan Burn called Bruno “an amazing player and an amazing captain for us during a very successful time” and wished him nothing but the best, apart from the two hours from 5.30pm on Saturday.

There will be no reunion with his close friend Joelinton, who is out with a thigh injury. And Newcastle are still looking for a long-term answer in midfield: they tried for Porto’s Victor Froholdt in the summer as a Bruno replacement and failed, and now Arsenal are watching him too, as we covered in Froholdt’s €85m clause and Arsenal’s interest.

Verdict: let the boos come

Bruno chose Arsenal and the champions are top of the league. A few boos on Tyneside are part of the deal, and the best players use that kind of night.

If he starts, keeps his head and helps Arsenal leave St James’ Park still clear at the top, the move will look a lot better than four league starts suggest. We expect him to be in the XI.

To Top
Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive latest Arsenal news and updates from our team.

Thank you! Check your email to confirm your subscription.